Mar
07

Another 9 month “Social Media Guru”

By Mark Kithcart

UPDATE 3/20/10: This post “struck a cord”, and not a good one, with some folks.  I stumbled across a post on Michael Brito’s Facebook wall that spoke to the exact sentiment I had in my post.  Ok, albeit it was more diplomatic – See Aaron Lewis’ blog link (and go check out his blog click here) and video at the bottom of this post to get the skinny…..

I attended Alex Mandossian’s reunion this past weekend at the Marriott in Millbrae.

A great event and Alex is a fantastic speaker.  There were numerous take-aways such as productivity, mental strengthening and much more.  The disappointment I experienced was from a standpoint of expectation.  I thought there would be much more about the “nuts and bolts” and how to get various aspects of systems in place to get traction in your business and on the internet.

I do agree though, you need the mental piece because without it, the “how-to’s” don’t matter.

The experiential nature of the event was good, however, it was very much geared to gratuitous networking and self-promotion.  Not that I’m opposed to it, but being a first timer I was a little taken aback and definitely not prepared to have 150 business cards to hand out and have my “pitch” honed to attract buyers (previous attendees were well prepared with special cards designed for the event).

The most interesting thing I am finding at events, like Alex’s, today are the number of “social media experts”.  I’m tired of hearing of another social media guru.  Anyone who has been on Facebook for the past 9 months is now a social media expert,  anyone who has been able to build their way to a 10,000 or greater following on twitter (which can be gamed extensively) is now a social media guru, anyone who lost their job in the past year is now a social media expert/guru.

I’m excited about the future of where we are going but social media experts should understand that social media is more than just Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn and various other places online to attack users with bad marketing messages.  I recently met a 9 month social media guru who was giving talks, booking speaking engagements and teaching groups how to “find their voice” online and in social media circles without having any idea of how to actually engage their audience to get traction and achieve results.

Social media is going to need some major overhauls to clear out the experts, gurus and riff-raff that might know something about social media but have no idea how to develop an overall online strategy to use all aspects of marketing, message development, traffic development, on-page/off-page SEO, website development and a comprehensive plan to fully engage their audience beyond just social media.  Social media is a place for transparent, interactive and engaging relationships and conversations but it should not be treated as the final frontier for monetization.

I look forward to the day I can go to a seminar and the social media guru’s I meet are really social media guru’s.

Here is a link to Aaron’s blog/video post – http://www.theaaronist.com/regarding-social-media-experts/

And here is the video – good stuff!!

Regarding “Social Media Experts” from Aaron Lewis on Vimeo.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Technorati
  • Live
  • LinkedIn
  • MySpace
Categories : Social Media
  • Great article and I do agree with you however as someone who was laid off 14 months ago I have used this time to engage in an arena that is driving the way business is now done, whether it be from an integrated marketing perspective or for business development. Those new to the sand box shouldn't be marketing themselves as experts but those that have been effected by downsizing and are taking the opportunity to develop a new skill set shouldn't be looked down upon by those more senior in the field of SM. I encounter this frequently and it is not only annoying but rude. I am new to SM but have been in the business world for 10 years. I offer consulting services that include SM but am always up front and honest with where my experience lies. This industry needs to be inclusive of new comers and not threatened by them and in time the bad ones will be weeded out, and a certification will come to the industry just as it has done in others. @NicoleGSimonds
  • Hi Nicole - thanks for stopping by and commenting. This post wasn't meant for you (but you probably already new that). The reason I know that it wasn't meant for you is, you would have never responded if you weren't authentic. Also I agree with you - in every industry newcomers are needed to bring fresh ideas and to challenge the ones already in place.

    The people that concern me are the folks who are selling social media as a panacea and that THEY are the ones who know how it works (a guru or expert) and have figured it all out within a few months. That doesn't sound like you at all.

    Congratulations on teaching yourself new ideas and diving in where most would not. Good luck in your journey and I would be more than happy to give you any advice or feedback during your journey. Welcome!
blog comments powered by Disqus